Extract - Vanilla. Vanilla is the most popular flavoring in the world. Because of its distinct fragrance and flavor; Vanilla extract will enhance the taste of all your cakes, cookies, and fruit pie fillings. You may also add Vanilla to iced coffee, milk shakes or any of your dairy recipes. Imitation Vanilla has a more potent flavor than the pure vanilla. Extract ingredients include: water, propylene glycol, flavorings and caramel color.